Services Granite Countertops Marble Countertops Quartzite Countertops Quartz & Porcelain Countertops Gallery Service Areas Park City & Deer Valley About Howard FAQ Contact / Free Estimate (801) 376-3856
Buyer's Guide

Choosing Your Countertop Stone

Granite vs. Marble vs. Quartzite vs. Quartz? We break down the pros, cons, and performance of each stone to help you choose the right surface for your Utah home.

At Granite Countertops of Utah, Howard Gerstner has fabricated and installed thousands of custom stone surfaces since 1984. Every stone we work with is premium slab-grade, and the right choice comes down to your space, your cooking habits, and the look you want to wake up to every day.

Quartz vs. Natural Stone (Granite, Marble & Quartzite)

This is the most common question in kitchen remodeling. Do you go with the zero-sealing convenience of engineered quartz, or the one-of-a-kind geological depth of natural granite, marble, or quartzite?

Quartz (Engineered) →

  • Non-porous: Never needs sealing
  • High stain and acid resistance
  • Consistent pattern & color across slabs
  • Tough against everyday chips and scratches

Natural Stone (Granite / Quartzite) →

  • Superior heat resistance for hot pans
  • 100% unique, one-of-a-kind natural slabs
  • Strong resale appeal in Utah luxury homes
  • Luminous crystalline depth that cannot be printed

Natural Marble vs. Natural Quartzite

Both natural marble and natural quartzite deliver sweeping, organic veining that engineered stone cannot replicate—but they behave very differently in a kitchen:

Natural Marble (Carrara / Calacatta) →

  • Unmatched classic Italian white & grey beauty
  • Naturally cool surface ideal for baking & pastry
  • Honed (matte) finish conceals everyday etching
  • Showstopping for islands, vanities & fireplaces

Natural Quartzite (Taj Mahal / Sea Pearl) →

  • Harder than granite (Mohs 7–8)
  • True marble-like movement without acid etching
  • Handles heavy cast-iron cookware and high heat
  • Ideal for high-traffic family kitchen islands

Quartz vs. Porcelain

Large-format sintered porcelain slabs are a strong option alongside engineered quartz, particularly for outdoor kitchens, fireplace walls, and modern thin-profile mitered islands. Explore our Quartz & Porcelain guide →

Choose Quartz if...

  • You want a full-body 3cm edge profile ( eased, ogee, or bullnose).
  • You prefer warm white backgrounds and subtle veining.
  • You want the most proven, low-maintenance indoor kitchen surface.

Choose Porcelain if...

  • You are building an outdoor kitchen (Porcelain is 100% UV-stable).
  • You want a sleek modern aesthetic or mitered waterfall island.
  • You want maximum heat resistance in a man-made slab.

Exotic & Specialized Stones

Soapstone: The Velvet Stone

Soapstone is a non-porous natural stone prized for its heat resistance and smooth, tactile feel. It develops a natural patina over time, and many homeowners treat it with food-safe mineral oil for a rich, dark charcoal finish.

Onyx: The Translucent Showpiece

Onyx is a semi-precious natural stone known for its translucency. When backlit with LED panels, an onyx bar top, fireplace feature, or powder room vanity glows with dramatic depth.

Limestone: Soft & Architectural

Limestone offers a warm, matte, earthy palette suited for master bath vanities, tub surrounds, and fireplace hearths where organic texture is the priority.

At-A-Glance Stone Comparison

Feature Granite Marble Quartzite Quartz Porcelain Soapstone
Material Type Natural Natural Natural Engineered Sintered Ceramic Natural
Hardness (Mohs) 6 – 7 3 – 4 7 – 8 ~7 7 – 8 2.5 – 3.5
Needs Sealing? Yes (1–2 yrs) Yes (6–12 mos) Yes (Annual) Never Never Mineral Oil (Opt)
Heat Resistance Excellent Very Good Excellent Moderate Excellent Superior
UV (Outdoor) Safe Indoor Preferred Safe Indoor Only 100% UV Safe Safe
Maintenance Low Moderate–High Low–Moderate Minimal Minimal Low

Expert Tip from Howard: See the Full Slab in Person

"The best way to choose is to touch the stone in person. We've seen homeowners fall in love with a small quartz sample, only to walk into a Salt Lake slab yard and find a full slab of natural granite, marble, or quartzite they had to have. I personally meet my clients at the stone warehouses so we can inspect the exact slabs together."

Salt Lake Stone Wholesalers Where We Meet Clients

MSI Surfaces → Arizona Tile → The Stone Collection → Daltile → GS Marble & Granite →

Most major slab warehouses are located in the Salt Lake City area. Call Howard at (801) 376-3856 to schedule your free in-home measurement and slab yard walkthrough.

Let's Get a Precise Estimate

Contact Howard today for a free in-home estimate. He will measure your space, discuss your stone options, and give you a clear quote.